How to Avoid Scam Scrap Dealers: 9 Red Flags Before You Ship
Precious metal scrap is one of the few commodities where the seller often cannot see what they are selling. A catalyst, a bucket of sludge or a batch of spent crucibles has no visible price tag — its value is decided entirely by an assay the seller may never witness and a settlement formula they may never read. That information gap is exactly what fraudulent dealers exploit. Every year, otherwise careful businesses lose thousands of dollars per lot to lowball assays, invented deductions and outright non-payment. Here are the nine red flags that expose a scam dealer — and the five-step check that takes ten minutes and protects every lot you ship.
Why Scrap Fraud Works: You Are Selling Invisible Value
When you sell copper, the buyer weighs it and the price is public. When you sell iridium-bearing slag or silver sludge, three separate numbers decide your payment: how much precious metal the material actually contains, what recovery rate the refiner will achieve, and what percentage of that recovered metal they agree to pay you. None of these is visible to the naked eye, and each one is an opportunity to mislead. Legitimate dealers manage this asymmetry with transparency — written assays, disclosed formulas, third-party verification. Scam dealers manage it with speed and vagueness, because a confused seller who is pressured to decide quickly is the easiest to underpay.
The 9 Red Flags of a Scam Scrap Dealer
Red Flag 1: An instant quote without an assay
“Send us photos and we’ll pay $X per kilo” sounds convenient, but no honest buyer can price heterogeneous precious metal scrap without testing it. A dealer who quotes before assaying is either guessing (and will renege later “after testing”) or planning to pay a flat lowball rate regardless of content. Real quotations come after sampling and analysis — see our guide to ICP vs XRF assay methods for what a genuine testing process looks like.
Red Flag 2: No written assay report
Verbal numbers evaporate. A settlement-grade buyer provides a written certificate stating the sample method, the assay result and the date. If the dealer’s response to “can I get that in writing?” is hesitation, you already have your answer.
Red Flag 3: Vague or shifting payable terms
Every legitimate offer contains three explicit numbers: assayed content, payable percentage and fees. Scam operations quote one flattering headline number and reveal “processing deductions” after your material is already in their hands — when your negotiating leverage is zero. Compare the net settlement across buyers, exactly as we recommend in our article on getting the best price for iridium scrap.
Red Flag 4: Pressure to ship before agreeing on terms
“Send the material first, we’ll settle after.” Once your lot crosses their gate, the only terms that exist are the ones they offer. Every shipment should be preceded by written, agreed terms: what will be tested, how, and on what basis you will be paid.
Red Flag 5: Unverifiable business identity
No legal entity name, no physical address, a website with no company history, “export-only” payment structures, or requests to deal through personal messaging accounts with no contract. Cross-check the company name against business registries — the same verification steps we detail in our guide to verifying a licensed PGM refiner.
Red Flag 6: Prices dramatically above every other quote
Counterintuitively, the scam is sometimes dressed up as generosity. A quote far above the market range is bait; once you ship, the “assay” comes back inexplicably low, or fees consume the premium. If one buyer’s offer is 30% above everyone else’s, ask why — and ask for the assay basis behind it.
Red Flag 7: Refusal to return or account for residues
Refining never recovers 100% of the metal. Honest dealers either disclose their residual treatment policy or return tailings on request. A dealer who claims “everything is recovered” or refuses to discuss residues is hiding one of the easiest places to skim value — a point we also cover for silver materials in our guide to silver sludge and contact recycling.
Red Flag 8: Cash-only or opaque payment channels
Cash on collection leaves no paper trail; offshore personal accounts with no invoice offer no recourse. Professional operations pay through documented business channels with invoices that match the settlement statement.
Red Flag 9: No chain-of-custody documentation
From pickup to settlement, your material should be traceable: sealed packaging, recorded weights at each transfer, sample splits preserved for both parties. A dealer with no custody process can claim your lot weighed less, assayed lower, or never arrived — and you cannot prove otherwise. This is why we emphasize sealed, documented packing in our guide to shipping precious metal scrap safely.
The 5-Step Verification Checklist (Ten Minutes, Every Lot)
- Verify the entity. Legal name, registration number, physical address, and how long they have operated. One registry search settles most of it.
- Ask for the testing method in writing. “Which assay method determines settlement — XRF screening or ICP/fire assay — and who can witness sampling?” A dealer who welcomes the question is telling you something.
- Get the full settlement formula. Assayed content × payable % − fees, on paper, before anything ships. Compare net-to-you across at least two buyers.
- Request sample split rights. You keep a sealed portion of the sample for independent re-testing if the number looks wrong.
- Document everything you ship. Photos, weights, sealed packaging, signed transfer notes. Documentation is your only leverage if a dispute arises.
What a Legitimate Dealer Looks Like
The contrast is easy to spot once you know the pattern. A real refiner tests before quoting, puts the assay and the settlement formula in writing, explains why low-grade material still costs money to process, discloses residual policies, and has operated from a verifiable address for years. They answer “can I see the certificate?” with a PDF, not an excuse. They also charge real fees — because real refining costs real money — and they will explain each line item. Free testing is normal (it wins business); free refining with no deductions is fiction.
Most sellers do not lose everything in one dramatic scam. They lose steadily, lot after lot, to dealers who pay “pretty good” prices on unverifiable numbers — which over a year costs more than the dramatic fraud would. The fix is not cynicism; it is the ten-minute checklist above, applied every time.
Want a second opinion on a quote you have received? Litop Metals has been purchasing and refining PGM and precious metal scrap — including mixed precious metal scrap — since 2005, with free ICP & XRF sample testing, written assay certificates, sample split rights and transparent settlement formulas. Send us your material description and the quote you were offered: contact our team for an honest comparison. Learn more about our testing and assay process first if you like.
